Skip to content
Thursday, November 19, 2026
Top Modern Pulse Zone

My Plan to Overhaul the Academy System and Help Youth Footballers

A standout among the most memorable instances of the football year occurred last week, observing a homegrown player surge forward from his defensive penalty area to net a winning finish.

Young prospects are invariably cherished by their team's supporters and, judging by early glimpses, the faithful are going to witness many more exceptional performances from him in the time to come.

However, for every player who makes it, there are thousands of other youngsters who are not successful beyond the various levels, and are forced to cope with a shattering rejection at a young age.

It is these players who are released of youth football that I am concerned about, because I believe the current framework does enough to inform them about their odds, or look after them when they are let go.

It needs an transformation and, after I retired, I authored my own study into the academy system, with suggestions for how it could be improved.

A Massive Investment – With Some Significant Benefits

My perspective on academies is not just as a former manager. My family members are in the programme, so I've got a personal interest too.

For all aspiring footballers, the dream of becoming a professional player is a unique one. The academy system has been put in place to give them the greatest chance to fulfil that dream, with a specific programme being implemented over a decade ago.

Currently, many thousands of boys are in the system, at clubs from the top flight down. It's an comprehensive set-up, with sessions at least three evenings a week and a fixtures schedule that takes up most of their weekends.

The equivalent programme is now being used by the rapidly expanding sport, women's football, too.

These setups are staffed at exceptional levels and offer work for trainers, physios, medical staff and many more support staff.

The infrastructure are of the top quality, with top-class indoor and outdoor surfaces. Education is included too, with tutors employed to run compulsory vocational programmes.

The financial commitment is enormous but, as we have seen, the teams at the top end are gaining substantial returns on that investment through temporary transfers and sales of the young players.

The performance of the Present System?

The main performance programme has been in effect for almost 15 years now, so how has it stood up to the scrutiny of time?

Academies now run a pre-academy programme for kids from the age of six, so if any of them complete the entire programme they would graduate at 21. That's longer than a child spends in compulsory education, and covers his entire childhood.

These kids are given with club uniform and coats, all branded up, and are identified by peers and relatives as being part of that club.

Their identity has, effectively, been etched on them at a early age and they also have to make a complete commitment to the academy programme.

That means training on three nights a week, and a fixtures programme occupying most of the weekend, are now a key component of a youngster's journey to follow his ambition.

From my experiences, in many cases what happens at school is seen as being a lower priority, with the academy assuming primary importance and becoming the primary focus of the child and his family's life.

Certain families see a pot of gold at the end of the rainbow if their child makes it and place immense pressure on their backs to make it.

Sadly, figures show the system has a profound mismatch of achievement and failure. We all see the successful ones, but we rarely notice those who are released.

We Must Be Honest About Their Odds

I don't want to take those aspirations away from aspiring players but we need to be honest with them about their likelihood of success.

While there are certain players a club will pinpoint as being future professionals, the reality is a large number of the players have only been on the programme to occupy the spots needed for training sessions and the weekend matches at each age group.

I genuinely think academies sufficiently communicate the understandings of these players or parents, about where they stand in the broader structure.

Players and parents need to be given a full evaluation of where they rate, so they can plan for the likely disappointment when it occurs.

Our academies have nurtured some outstanding talent and there is greater attention paid to player welfare now than in the past, but let's also incorporate a bit more priority on openness too.

More Priority on Schooling

As I noted above, I feel many youth players joining academies actually listen more closely of their trainers at times than they do of their schoolteachers.

It's vital this is acknowledged within the academy system, and youth managers communicate this principle to the coaches at each age group.

This phenomenon itself is nothing new. Guidance played a significant part in my development, and sports teachers and coaches were always held in immense regard.

But, for anyone running an academy, they must make sure the coaches are given clear direction and appreciation of their role because of the sway they have.

Levels of respect, conduct and effort should be as high as they are in any educational environment – and should apply to the scholastic side of the child's life there too.

The system I have proposed would have greater emphasis on academics and mentoring – for guardians as well as the young players – and also planning for what comes next if they are dropped aged 16.

My Plan to Help Youth Players

I would structure academies within a number of zones, each run by a director and partner them with accredited schools and colleges.

Before they get to apprenticeship level, players would be assessed at 14 to see what education pathway is appropriate for them.

At 16, players taking apprenticeships would enrol in a compulsory combined education programme with the academic partners.

At the same time, the players who are released at 16, can begin a full-time dual educational programme with the schools or colleges.

The advantage for them would be the provision of a new competitive programme where the schools and colleges would

By

Brian Carroll

Elena Voss is a tech enthusiast and lifestyle blogger with a passion for uncovering modern trends and sharing actionable insights.

Top Modern Pulse Zone

Type to search articles.